Sign In

    organic wine: better in any way?

    Last updated 1 day 9 hours ago

    I just read an article by Miles Edlmann in World of Fine Wine about wines made from organic grapes. This is a topic I think and talk about quite a bit, and the article inspired me to write out some of my own thoughts, for which I will borrow some of Edlmannâ??s information. I want to start out by saying that I am very much interested in doing whatâ??s best for my own body and for the environment. I eat almost entirely organic produce and buy organic whenever possible with almost everything else. Knowing that, it might surprise you to learn that I drink almost no wine that is made from certified organic grapes and absolutely no wine that is considered in this country to be â??organic wineâ??. Iâ??d like to briefly outline my reasoning for choosing to buy and drink the way I do. There are two primary reasons. First, an organic certification does nothing to ensure farming practices that are better for the land than another approach. Second, that certification does nothing to ensure that the wine is any better (or less bad, depending on how you view that one) for the health of the consumer. Nothing. You might find that difficult to believe, so here are a few quick facts to back it up. The most commonly used antifungal treatment for certified organic vines, and really the only â??organicâ?? option available to combat downy mildew, is copper sulfate. Copper sulfate is EXTREMELY toxic to animals and to the environment. Edlmann mentions in his article that a single dose of 300 ppm (parts per million) killed 50% of rats in a lab study, and that â??[t]oxic effects have been reported in humans at levels as low as 11 ppm.â?? Furthermore, copper sulfate does not readily degrade in the environment, and itâ??s highly water soluble. It runs off very easily if thereâ??s rain soon after application, and if not, it bonds to particles in the soil and builds up year after year. What does that mean for the environment? Well, the runoff can be bad â??since a concentration of less than 1mg per liter will kill 50 percent of exposed fish within 48 hours.â?? (Edlmann) Copper, a heavy metal, is also excellent at killing microorganisms, which happens in water systems as well as in the vineyards themselves, where in France, copper levels at 10 times the maximum limit for US farms have been discovered. Even that maximum limit for US vineyards is going to ensure that those extremely important microorganisms have been wiped out. As far as the human toxicity that I mentioned, downy mildew can easily ruin an entire crop, and copper sulfate can be applied directly to the grapes as late as one week before harvest in those certified organic vineyards. I know that gets a bit technical and focuses on a single treatment, but the use of that treatment is extremely widespread in certified organic vineyards, being used by every one of them out of necessity in some regions. I think all of that illustrates the point that the health of the vineyard and that of the consumer is largely dependent on how much the grower and winemaker care about those things in organic or â??conventionalâ?? scenarios, and that the growerâ??s options can be limited to exclusively harmful compounds if they are to rightfully maintain their organic certification. The relevance of all of this information is that producers using organic certifications as a marketing tool donâ??t necessarily have anyoneâ??s best interest in mind besides that of their own bank accounts. I would argue that such is the case with most producers using organic certifications as a marketing tool. And guess what? If they have it on the label, theyâ??re using it as a marketing tool. There are a lot of producers out there who farm organically but havenâ??t paid for the expensive certification because they do it that way out of true caring rather than monetary incentive. The famed Domaine Huet and Francois Chidaine in the Loire Valley are great examples. There are others, such as the prestigious Chateau Margaux, who farm almost entirely organically but donâ??t want to get certified so that they can keep their options open and use the best treatment available at any given time. Chateau Margaux sells for about $1000 per bottle, and they certainly spare no expense when it comes to making the best wine possible, as well as being extremely concerned with the ongoing health of their vineyard land. On the other hand, youâ??ve got one of the largest producers of certified organic wine in this country blatantly lying to their customers. (see my earlier blog post on sulfites at http://www.liquorstoresboston.com/749100/2013/08/30/our-daily-lies-the-sulfite-issue.html) Knowing that company intentionally spreads falsehoods to promote their brand, I donâ??t trust them at all to care about environmental sustainability or the health of their customers. Our Daily Red even lies about what organic viticulture is on their website, saying â??[n]o pesticides, herbicides, fungicides, synthetic fertiliziers [sic] or chemicals are allowed on the vines or in the soil,â?? when herbicides and fungicides are definitely allowed and used as long as they qualify as â??organicâ??. I think this one producer, responsible for several brands, illustrates the point that there isnâ??t a lot of transparency or even honesty being used to sell these massive organic wine brands. For â??organic wineâ?? in the US, growers can spray loads of sulfur on the vines, sometimes leaving residue in the juice, but sulfur canâ??t be used in making the wine. If you can figure that one out, let me know. I donâ??t think there is a rational explanation. I donâ??t know who is to blame for regulations that donâ??t make sense, but itâ??s another example of the smoke and mirrors involved in marketing these wines. I have a severe intolerance for companies intentionally deceiving their customer base, but even before I knew about these instances, I had a simple philosophy when it came to choosing wine. I wanted it to taste good and be well valued. If it was made with organically grown grapes, I saw that as a little bit of a bonus, but certainly not a deciding factor unless all other factors were equal. At that time and now, I havenâ??t seen many wines that say â??organicâ?? on the label and taste really good for their price and category. There are a few, but most times, I choose to drink something else for the same money that I think is significantly better. When it comes to my health and the health of the land, specific details are needed to make informed decisions, and those details can be difficult, if not impossible, to find. Generalization can lead to false conclusions in many situations, but what I generally find is that smaller producers and higher quality producers are usually the ones that are putting a lot of caring into how they treat their land and what goes into the bottle. So, Iâ??ll happily drink wine from my favorite producers, relatively small and producing high quality wine, and trust them to make the decisions which they think are best.

    DEPOT DEAL: huge discount on a 90 point Spanish red

    Last updated 6 days ago

    This is the kind of deal that I know quite a few of you love.  We've been selling Evodia for several vintages now.  We usually have a sale price on it, and it does quite well.  It has always been a lot of wine for a little money.  Now we've got the new vintage, highly rated, at a deeper discount than ever before.  This is a big wine, great for those who like a lot of flavor in a soft, easy-drinking red.  Check out the reviews:
     
     
    "(100% garnacha; no oak): Vivid purple. Powerful aromas of blueberry, blackberry, woodsmoke and Indian spices. Displays supple, open-knit flavors of smoky dark berries, bitter chocolate and candied flowers. Seductive right now, with a sweet floral pastille element carrying through a long, smoky, tannin-free finish. An amazing value."
    90 points
    Stephen Tanzer
     
     
    "An Eric Solomon custom cuvee, the 2012 Evodia is 100% Grenache from a vineyard planted at more than 2,000 feet in pure decomposed slate soils. Some of the Grenache vines are over 100 years of age. The wine exhibits good density, plenty of richness, not the complexity or ethereal qualities of several of his other custom cuvees, but beautiful fruit, a luscious texture and a hedonistic mouthfeel as well as finish. Enjoy this remarkable value over the next 2-3 years."
    88 points
    Robert Parker
     
     
    sound good?  Here's the deal:
    2012 Evodia Garnacha, Calatayud, Spain
    90 ST, 88 RP
     
     
    Regular Price: $12.99
     
    D&L Sale Price: $9.99
     
    Buy 12+ bottles and get them for 
    $6.99 each!
     
     
    The wine is in stock at all locations.
    Please email leahdion@dandlwine.com and tell us your preferred pickup location for orders of 12 or more bottles.  For smaller quantities, you can either email us at leahdion@dandlwine.com or stop by and pick some up while supplies last.  Thanks for reading!
     
    -Doug Schulman, DWS, CWE

     

    DEPOT DEAL: serious Napa red for a not-so-serious price

    Last updated 19 days ago

    Cameron Hughes has done it again.  He has put out a wine of very high quality from a prestigious, small, expensive area which costs far less than most of its peers.  We're so excited about this particular release that we bought 41 of the 47 cases available in Massachusetts!  So, supply is limited to that, and there will be no more once it's gone.  On the plus side, we'll be one of the only places selling the wine, and we've got a low sale price to offer.

    First, a bit about where it's from. Atlas Peak is a small, high elevation sub-region of the Napa Valley.  With only a little over 3% of Napa's total planted vineyard area, this is a place that takes the consistency and exclusivity of the larger area (Napa) to an even greater extreme.  This Meritage (Bordeaux-style blend) shows the class of wines coming from Atlas Peak without carrying the typical price tag.

    The most important thing is how the wine tastes.  There are no professional reviews that I can find, so I will offer my own tasting note:

    The nose features luscious aromas of plum, black cherry, black currant, cedar, mocha, and subtle eucalyptus.  The first thing evident on first sip is the silky texture that caresses the palate.  There is an elegance to this wine, but still plenty of concentration.  The aromatic components all carry through and evolve into a complete finish that slowly fades away.

    Here's the wine:

    Atlas Peak, Napa Valley, CA

    Regular Price: $17.99

    D&L Sale Price: $13.99

    The wine is in stock at all locations. Feel free to stop by and pick some up.  Thanks for reading!

    -Doug Schulman, DWS, CWE

     

    WINE OF THE WEEK: discounted 90 point Spanish red

    Last updated 26 days ago

    This wine has already found some fans with the past couple of vintages.  The new vintage is even better, has a very positive review, and we're selling it for less money.

    Here's the review from Josh Raynolds of International Wine Cellar:


    "Brilliant ruby.  Lively red berry and Asian spice aromas are deepened by notes of mocha and licorice.  Taut and linear on entry, then fleshier in the middle, offering fresh raspberry and cherry compote flavors and a touch of succulent herbs.  Shows very good energy and focus, finishing with lingering spiciness and a note of tangy berry skin."

    90 points - IWC

    And the wine:

    2012 Can Blau

    Montsant, Spain

    Regular Price: $17.99

    D&L Sale Price: $14.99

    Buy 6+ bottles and get them for
    $12.99 each!

    The wine is in stock at both Waltham locations. Not available for online purchaces. Please email leahdion@dandlwine.com and tell us your preferred pickup location for orders of 6 or more bottles.  Otherwise, feel free to stop by and pick some up this weekend or later.  Also, let us know if you want some sent to Woburn.

     

    Annual Spring Tasting- Complimentary Event!

    Last updated 1 month ago

Follow Me on Pinterest


  • Hours:

  • 12:00 PM to 6:00 PM Sunday
  • 8:00 AM to 11:00 PM Monday
  • 8:00 AM to 11:00 PM Tuesday
  • 8:00 AM to 11:00 PM Wednesday
  • 8:00 AM to 11:00 PM Thursday
  • 8:00 AM to 11:00 PM Friday
  • 8:00 AM to 11:00 PM Saturday


Links

  • Recent Posts
    • Loading posts... Spinner
  • View All
  • Recent Comments
    • Loading comments... Spinner
  • Popular Tags
    • Loading tags... Spinner